20/10/2024
'NEWCASTLE COASTAL GEOTRAIL' BEATS 'BATHERS WAY COASTAL WALK' HANDS DOWN'
For those discussion group members who happened to tune into SBS last week to watch the latest iteration of 'Great Australian Walks' (focusing on Newcastle's famed 'Bathers Way Coastal Walk) they would be surprised to learn that this walk follows in length just part of what has been recently created as the more extensive Newcastle Geotrail. Yes, the NSW Geological Survey has created a far more informative and interesting geotrail that can be studied at https://bit.ly/48iQXSv rather than what the viewers were served up by the presenter in this TV program.
Apart from the rambling discourse about coastal swimming pools and convicts, the lifestyle of First National people prior to European settlement, shipping disasters, the great Newcastle earthquake links to a dreamtime story, coal mining, Macedonian communities and the BHP steel works etc - all worthy cultural heritage elements, the SBS program was devoid of any substance about natural heritage features. The failure to even identify the coal seams outcropping in the cliff faces was woeful given the very reason why colonial settlers selected this place for early colonial development!
Having watched a number of episodes of this program, it is apparent that the producers have not thoroughly researched these places and to ensure that the presenters are able to interview a range of local specialists expert in the 'A', 'B', and 'C' domains. It is truly arguable whether or not the production of this series can live up to the standard which would be expected for a quality documentary. Surely, SBS can do better than this!