20/03/2025
No, really? Well, it depends 🧐
This winter has not been very cold in Scotland. The snow and ice more ephemeral than ever, underpinned by a constant ni**le; might this be the end of winters as we have known them?
For those that hold winter sports close to their heart this poses a predicament. How do you continue to do what you love, what makes you, you, when you can no longer do it at home?
A common response is to fly abroad and seek out snow where it still clings on. But this in itself is a predicament. How can it be right that by escaping a problem - no winter at home - you are contributing to the problem - travelling, most likely flying, abroad.
I recently spoke at an event discussing the nature of changing Scottish winters. Someone asked ‘should I give up on Ben Nevis and go to Norway for my ice climbing?’. I was grateful for the directness of this, but I’ve only since formed my response.
It depends.
What I encourage is reflection, on what it is about Ice Climbing/skiing/winter routes that are so important to you? Can this only be replicated by that activity or is it something broader? A challenge? A test of resilience? A portal into a unique world?
If so, can you find it elsewhere, in different corners of winter as it still exists here?
Can you rethink your idea of what winter ‘should’ look like and find satisfaction in a new form of exploration at home? If you can do that then you don’t need to go to Norway!
If this alternative is a no-go, then maybe you must go. But you have to be happy in the knowledge that you are part of the problem. Entrenched in a culture where you feel entitled to fulfil your own needs at the cost of others, fundamentally our planets.
As humans we are too good at getting stuck in the same old patterns. We must do ‘X’ in order to feel/be ‘Y’.
It’s time for a shake up. A reflection on the values that really matter. Hold them upfront and centre and let them determine the best course of action.
Can you really be true to what matters most to you and carry on as ‘normal’?
You never know embracing change might mean you happen upon something even more fulfilling than Scottish winter as we have know it.
Discuss…