09/21/2023
MAYKING, KY., September 30, 1935 --
Jim Flinchum was a drinking man.
Not a rip-roaring, knee-crawling drunk, not a fighting drunk, but he was known to take a swallow or two of libations of the intoxicating variety now and again, and remain a generally quiet and peaceful man.
By day, Jim was a sawmiller, a farmer and raised a tolerable big family, most of whom were grown. The family lived at Sergent, a few miles upriver from Whitesburg.
The last time anybody saw Jim Flinchum – at least all of him at one time – was on Sunday, September 29, 1935.
He was around Mayking at the time and seemed sober and fine. But Jim never came home that night and he never showed up at the sawmill the next morning.
People went looking for him, and they sure enough found him back behind Charlie Hogg's house at Mayking. Jim Flinchum's body – what was left of it – was lying on the railroad tracks, run over by the L&N.
While his body was badly damaged, his head was a different matter. It just wasn't there at all.
In spite of the best efforts of the police and the neighbors, come Saturday, when The Mountain Eagle newspaper was published,
there was still no sign of Jim Flinchum's head.
Nearly two weeks went by when word reached Whitesburg of a grisly discovery and an even grislier result.
It seems that somewhere below Neon, a human head – singed and covered in ash – had been found, and folks from Whitesburg to Neon were breathless with excitement and horror.
Despite the unlikely proposition that two severed human heads were rolling around on the railroad tracks between Mayking and Neon, no one was willing to jump to the conclusion that this now nearly 3-week-lifeless noggin was the unclaimed property of Headless Jim Flinchum.
With no knowledge of DNA nearly 90 years ago, officials in the railroad town of Neon did the only reasonable thing.
They put the head on exhibition.
Within a week county officials determined that the head did indeed belong to Jim Flinchum and not to some other unfortunately decapitated resident who had somehow escaped notice.
Then, and only then, was Jim Flinchum's head reunited with his body and laid permanently to rest.