10/24/2024
It has been said before that those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it. This statement is true by virtue of its logical form; nevertheless, I do not believe that we ever really think about what it means.
Looking back on last weekend’s “Ghostly and Gruesome Historical Walking Tour” (tickets are still available for upcoming walks) I wanted to circle back to something we talked about that resonates with the idea that history is vital to understanding the present and preparing for the future. Elements of our walks (including our non-spooky walks) always attempt to tie local history into the greater tapestry of historical events.
Anti-immigrant racism is not new (and is currently on the rise in Canada), and it has never needed different skin tones to be violent and bigoted. The Irish – well into the twentieth century – experienced oppression, abuse, and disenfranchisement, either for being Irish or for being Catholic. Eventually they would be able to treat the next wave of immigrants with the same treatment that they received themselves. We do not learn from the past, but why? The justification of “it happened to me so it should happen to you” shows a deep lack of understanding about our own history, at a local level and a national level.
This begs the question, why don’t we learn from the past? It is – fundamentally – rooted in how history is taught to us. The teaching of history occurs through Cole’s Notes, that is, the bullet points covering the perceived “Big Events.” While those big events matter, they do not paint the whole picture, and we lose something. We only learn an abridged story.
History, both the learning and the teaching of history, requires relatable stories.
Doing these walking tours reminds me that plaques, statues, monuments, etc do not tell us anything real about history, rather they attempt to glorify something that someone felt deserved it. We do not stop anywhere with one of those, instead we have visited the Archives, we have done the research, and we have considered what we want to say about history.
We try to learn about the things that happened in the past, and we try to see how that impacts today. History is the greatest story ever written, and we write it everyday.
Belleville Downtown District Community Archives of Belleville and Hastings County