12/03/2024
Environmental Updates
An excerpt from our monthly ZERO report. As this is a subscription report, the following item is not from the current edition.
Royal Caribbean greenwashing
The Royal Caribbean* cruising group targets net zero emissions for 2050*. Maybe, but over the next 18-24 months it will do nothing except decide what to do - ‘develop objectives’.
Other commentary:
-RC reports the delivery of a net-zero cruise ship by 2035, although it awaits ‘solid partnerships’ (which sounds like financial incentives) from many others, listing governments, suppliers, shipyards.
-RC reports that it has ‘consistently delivered [ships] 20-25% more effective’. RC does not ‘deliver’ ships - it takes delivery of ships - and so we do not understand its meaning. Also, ‘effective’ can have many meanings, not necessarily EF.
-Its Silversea brand is due to launch a ‘hybrid-powered’ ship in summer 2023. But not into operations; where and to do what is not clear. RC says this ship will offset 12% of a part of it emissions - but it is not clear what this will represent overall. The elements of the hybrid power are not given.
-It also plans delivery of a ship (sometimes described ‘Evolution Project’, sometimes ‘Project Evolution’) that will eliminate ‘local emissions’ in port. Once again, much is not clear: no dates given; by definition, ‘local’ emissions can be only in ports; what share do those emissions represent of total emissions; and which emissions - CO2?
-Sadly, WWF (World Wildlife Fund) participates in RC’s greenwashing. In 2016, RC and WWF signed what they called a ‘partnership’. RC set targets for 2020 (details not known) to reduce its ‘environmental footprint’ and ‘support’ ocean conservation. It reports that it met or exceeded its targets (except, ironically, for sustainable sourcing for seafood, now due in 2022).
-WWF supports RC actions. ‘Achieving net zero emissions no later than 2050 [*] will require innovation and collaboration to scale, and WWF is pleased to be a contributor to progress to this important step.’ WWF threatens its credibility with such statements.
*Notes:
-Royal Caribbean Group is the trading name of Royal Caribbean Cruises. As well as that brand, it has Celebrity Cruises, Silversea Cruises, and 50% of the operator of Hapag-Lloyd and TUI cruiselines. RCG operates 58 ships.
-2050 is 30 years from now and we believe an unconvincing target, for public relations purposes only. 2030 would be a tough target, but surely 2035 is the furthest credible date?
-At press time, we had not received an answer to our request for clarifications.
‘end