01/18/2024
Did you know in the late 1800s on the shores of Geneva Lake stood a hotel larger than the Grand Hotel on Mackinac Island? 🤔
Called Pishcotaqua Park House Hotel, it opened in 1880 and was the largest in the Midwest. It was a stunning hotel with verandas on every level and it should have been a roaring success. But the hotel struggled to survive financially going through multiple owners and a foreclosure. Operating as a temperance resort likely didn’t help. When brewer John Cooke acquired the hotel 1890 that changed immediately. Cooke brought in alcohol and changed the name to Cooke Parke Villa Hotel.
Just when the Hotel looked like it was turning the corner, in 1891 parts of it were destroyed by a fire. The hotel was remodeled and rebuilt only to be completely destroyed the following year by another fire. But Cooke loved the area so much he converted the surviving billiards hall into his home and called it Ara Glen. It still stands today as a residence. Eventually the property was subdivided and now you'll find Knollwood subdivision and Ara Glen subdivision on either side.
Listen to more great stories like this one as you walk the path with the VoiceMap app.
https://voicemap.me/tour/lake-geneva-wisconsin/geneva-lake-shore-path-audio-guide-21-miles-of-stories
Photos courtesy of Lake Geneva Public Library