05/11/2024
It's 1900 and "the season" is gearing up. A newspaper article of the time said, "The demand for modern cottages has exceeded the supply, and a large addition to the permanent winter cottage colony has been made. J. Edward Addicks, the Boston millionaire, will occupy the large Anderson cottage with his family. He will keep his steam yacht, Now Then, here during the winter. G. W. Folsom and family of Lenox, will return to the Carr cottage, and Mason Young and family have leased the Ammidown villa for another winter. Franklin W. Smith and family, of Boston, will take possession of the Moorish "Villa Zorayda" some time in January."
The picture is of the Carr Cottage at 46 Avenida Menendez, which is now a restaurant. In their blog they share this information below.
History of 46 Avenida Menendez
Originally built of tabby (a type of concrete made from burnt oyster shells, water, sand, and ash) during the first Spanish period, this private residence was owned by Señorita Juana Navarro. Juana later married Señor Salvador Francisco de Porras and together had 9 children, one of them named Catalina.
In 1764, at just 11 years old, Catalina and her family were forced to evacuate from their treasured home at 46 Avenida Menendez to Cuba when Florida became an English Colony after nearly 200 years of Spanish rule. British soldiers moved into vacated homes and the de Porras house was claimed by Walton & Company of New York. Twenty years later, in 1784, the British were forced out when East Florida returned to Spanish rule. Catalina and her new husband, along with her now widowed mother, returned from Cuba to claim the estate that was rightfully theirs. The once grand homes of St. Augustine were in such neglect and disrepair that the governor was planning to auction them off or have them demolished. Fortunately for Catalina and her family, after much persistence and intervention, they were able to save their family home from utter ruin.
The beautiful bayfront home burnt to ashes in 1887 with much of the city’s other buildings along Avenida Menendez and the plaza. It was immediately rebuilt to its original beauty (this time with poured concrete instead of tabby) by Buroughs E. Carr, who started a general store next to the home using sketches done in 1840.
W.I. Drysdale, famous for the St. Augustine alligator farm and descendant of John Drysdale, lived at 46 Avenida Menendez until 1976 when he sold the family home to Puerta Verde Restaurant. Later, the building became Chart House Restaurant, then Catalina’s Garden (named after Catalina de Porras), and as of the late 90’s, Harry’s Seafood Bar and Grille, which still stands today.
(No citations were given for this blog entry by Harry's.)