09/27/2024
DID YOU KNOW?? 🤔 Before the Ponce de Leon Hotel (aka Flagler College now) was built, do you think that location was bare land, empty of structures? We are talking 1886 when Flagler wanted to build and that area was swampy land (at the end of Maria Sanchez Creek) and orange groves. And it was outside the walled city parameters that existed not too long before.
Well, if you did think that, you would be mistaken.
SUNNYSIDE HOTEL. (below) Captain Thomas House built a house for his family, naming it Sunnyside House, in 1876. Shortly afterwards, he decided to open it to the public as a hotel. Rooms booked for $2.50 each.
When Henry Flagler came along, he thought a hotel here was a wonderful idea. But he wanted that location. And of course, Henry Flagler usually got what he wanted. 😏 He also thought he could 'do better'.
BUT, Henry did have interests in architecture and tried to preserve as much as he could. So when he bought out the Sunnyside Hotel, he did not destroy it. He chose to move it. . . .across the street where the Casa Monica stands today. He solicited his friend Franklin Smith (who's personal home was what is now Villa Zorayda on King St too) to run the Sunnyside Hotel in it's new location. This happened in Dec of 1886.
(Ponce de Leon opened in winter of 1888)
Well Franklin also saw bigger potential too and decided to build his own hotel as well, so once again Sunnyside was on the move.
However, this time, the house/hotel was broken up into four separate buildings, which were scattered around St. Augustine.
Franklin Smith's new hotel venture was the Casa Monica, on the same grounds it stands today (it has gone through name and purpose changes like many things, but is back to it's original name and grandeur now)
The sections of Sunnyside are mostly gone now EXCEPT for ONE. It is at 525 W. King St, as the St John's Housing Partnership.
In 2001, it became the very FIRST official Historic Landmark named in St. Johns county, as being the oldest wooden hotel still standing pre-dating the Flagler era.