The Honest Sutler

The Honest Sutler The Honest Sutler offers Civil War era clothing made with historical accuracy in mind. Please feel free to contact any one of us with any questions or needs!
(30)

-Nathan Kalvitis, Tyler Grecco, Jeorge Galutia, and Conor Sullivan are dedicated living historians who offer accurate reproductions of Civil War era clothing and equipment at affordable prices. Our mission is to uniform living historians with quality reproductions and to give the customer a honest, friendly, and pleasant experience. We look forward to doing business with you!
-The "Honest Sutler"

name is in no way an offense to other reenacting sutlers, but rather a play on the period view of the dishonest, scheming military sutler.

***Refund Policy: All products are custom made, we do not offer refunds on any order once payment has been processed.***

Back to Enlisted Frocks!
08/30/2024

Back to Enlisted Frocks!

I never get sick of Columbus depot jackets. This one features Ben Tarts Sumac mix. More to come!
08/16/2024

I never get sick of Columbus depot jackets. This one features Ben Tarts Sumac mix. More to come!

Schuylkill Arsenal and W. B. Button.
08/09/2024

Schuylkill Arsenal and W. B. Button.

Junior Officers private purchase sack coat.
08/02/2024

Junior Officers private purchase sack coat.

Thank you again to all who ordered trousers and contract shirts this past winter, the last of those orders will be finis...
07/19/2024

Thank you again to all who ordered trousers and contract shirts this past winter, the last of those orders will be finished up and sent out in the next week or so. - Nathan

I have had a lot of folks asking me about RCB “royal blue” trousers. I recently came across this wool, which I thought l...
07/12/2024

I have had a lot of folks asking me about RCB “royal blue” trousers. I recently came across this wool, which I thought looked the part. If I have some interested I can justify buying a roll. Send me a message or leave a comment if you would be interested in purchasing french blue Richmond trousers.

The swatch was photographed in the shade and sun. It is a very safe royal blue in my opinion, not too bright or electric blue and has a nice subtle mix to the color.

Thank you to all who ordered tan contract shirts! And to all those patiently waiting on 1/2 inch tin buttons for theirs....
06/21/2024

Thank you to all who ordered tan contract shirts! And to all those patiently waiting on 1/2 inch tin buttons for theirs. I wish I had been able to get a photo of the whole lot. Next time!

What contract shirt color would you like to see next? More Tan, Grey, Blue, Brown? - Nathan

Headed to France, the most in-depth reproduction of the Lewis jacket I have ever done. This took me every bit as long as...
06/14/2024

Headed to France, the most in-depth reproduction of the Lewis jacket I have ever done. This took me every bit as long as an enlisted frock. - Nathan

A neat one made last month, based off Seymours Louisiana jacket and featuring Ben Tart Logwood Satinette.
06/05/2024

A neat one made last month, based off Seymours Louisiana jacket and featuring Ben Tart Logwood Satinette.

A small group buy of red flannel citizens shirts. I have a good amount of red flannel left, if anyone is interested in a...
05/29/2024

A small group buy of red flannel citizens shirts. I have a good amount of red flannel left, if anyone is interested in a shirt send us a message. - Nathan

A great looking pair of Richmond depot trousers featuring Ben Tart yarn dyed jeans.
05/24/2024

A great looking pair of Richmond depot trousers featuring Ben Tart yarn dyed jeans.

A completely hand-sewn unlined SA blouse. I can’t remember the last time I made one of these. Upon the costumers request...
05/15/2024

A completely hand-sewn unlined SA blouse. I can’t remember the last time I made one of these. Upon the costumers request, this blouse features both shades of Ben Tarts amazing sack coat flannel.

If you’re sick of roasting in a blouse with a lining thats three times thicker than most originals, send us a message. Unlined variants start at $245.00.

Welt pocket federal trousers look extra good with Sergeant stripes.
05/03/2024

Welt pocket federal trousers look extra good with Sergeant stripes.

Can we all agree to order MSJs with altered collars from now on?
05/01/2024

Can we all agree to order MSJs with altered collars from now on?

Schuylkill Arsenal suit ready for The Battle of the Wilderness!
04/26/2024

Schuylkill Arsenal suit ready for The Battle of the Wilderness!

W.B. Button mounted trousers, part of an order being sent to the Manassas National Battlefield Park. Two of each militar...
04/12/2024

W.B. Button mounted trousers, part of an order being sent to the Manassas National Battlefield Park. Two of each military size, 1- 4.

Another winter issue Houston Depot jacket.
04/11/2024

Another winter issue Houston Depot jacket.

Columbus Depot jacket group buy — This CD variant is absolutely my favorite jacket to make. - Nathan
03/29/2024

Columbus Depot jacket group buy — This CD variant is absolutely my favorite jacket to make. - Nathan

A winter Houston Depot suit as described by Edward C. Wharton.
03/15/2024

A winter Houston Depot suit as described by Edward C. Wharton.

Federal private purchase trousers.
03/07/2024

Federal private purchase trousers.

DARK BLUE FEDERAL TROUSERS — Send us a message if you’d like to pick up a pair or to inquire about the different styles ...
03/01/2024

DARK BLUE FEDERAL TROUSERS —

Send us a message if you’d like to pick up a pair or to inquire about the different styles we offer!

Another recently finished dress coat -  I am offering $50 off Federal enlisted frocks if you order in the month of Febru...
02/08/2024

Another recently finished dress coat - I am offering $50 off Federal enlisted frocks if you order in the month of February. Send me a message if your interested! - Nathan

Just a few yards of tan flannel left for contract shirts — Send me a message if you would like to have one made! Thanks ...
02/01/2024

Just a few yards of tan flannel left for contract shirts — Send me a message if you would like to have one made!

Thanks to everyone who already ordered one, I can’t wait to see these come together. - Nathan

Another beautiful enlisted frock out the door! Thanks to all those who ordered one this past summer. Send us a message i...
01/27/2024

Another beautiful enlisted frock out the door! Thanks to all those who ordered one this past summer.

Send us a message if you’d like to jump in on our spring run of dress coats. - Nathan

The start of a large run of W.B. Button contract mounted trousers — Send us a message if you’d like to order a pair of t...
01/18/2024

The start of a large run of W.B. Button contract mounted trousers —

Send us a message if you’d like to order a pair of trousers or to inquire about the various fabrics and styles we offer!

🚨Dark blue trousers coming soon🚨

Columbus Depot jackets! I am offering a limited run of Columbus Depot jackets starting at $225.00. Send me a message if ...
01/12/2024

Columbus Depot jackets!

I am offering a limited run of Columbus Depot jackets starting at $225.00. Send me a message if you are interested in picking one up or if you’d like to inquire about different options for jean, facings, and buttons.

This particular Columbus Depot reproduction is a blast to make — Featuring lots of machine stitching, blue needle thread vs. mismatched brown bobbin thread, and two interior patch pockets.

Something about a red overcoat lining or red flannel shirt is extra fun to make this time of year — Seeing these garment...
12/30/2023

Something about a red overcoat lining or red flannel shirt is extra fun to make this time of year — Seeing these garments in the field, adding a pop of color to an otherwise drab scene, always reminds me of the countless 19th century artists like Winslow Homer, Eastman Johnson and Thomas Waterman Wood.

Beautiful enlisted frock out the door. I love the side profile on these. More to come soon!
12/21/2023

Beautiful enlisted frock out the door. I love the side profile on these. More to come soon!

You asked for it! Tan flannel contract shirts are now available to order. Send us a message if you’d like to pick one up...
11/30/2023

You asked for it! Tan flannel contract shirts are now available to order. Send us a message if you’d like to pick one up!

Just finished! — Federal trousers with welted or “slash” pockets can be a neat way to change up your impression without ...
11/17/2023

Just finished! — Federal trousers with welted or “slash” pockets can be a neat way to change up your impression without going crazy. You will undoubtedly come across the odd pair of these while looking at photos of the original cast.

p.s. This may have been a somewhat sought after style for keeping your valuables safe. There are several examples of trousers altered to carry the pockets on the front panel like this. I also recall a letter from a soldier asking that his trousers be made with pockets on the front.

Address

170 Fairfield Drive
Rochester, NY
14620

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Honest Sutler posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share



You may also like